Probate appraisal checklist: This checklist helps Atlanta executors gather the information an appraiser needs for a probate appraisal Georgia assignment or date-of-death appraisal before work begins.
- Confirm the valuation date and any alternate valuation date.
- Arrange property access or document why access is unavailable.
- Gather evidence of the property’s condition at the effective date.
- Document work completed after the date of death.
- Find prior appraisals, purchase records, and listing history.
- Collect insurance records and repair estimates.
- Identify everyone who should receive or rely on the report.
Estimated reading time: 7 minutes
When you serve as an executor or administrator, depending on the estate's purpose and the advice of counsel or the tax professional, an estate appraisal may be an early practical step in documenting real property. The process is straightforward when the appraiser has the right information, but missing records can make a retrospective assignment more time-consuming.
This checklist is not a substitute for legal advice and does not identify every duty or filing requirement applicable to an executor or administrator.
This guide explains what to collect, why each item matters, and what happens when the information is incomplete.
Key terms used in this checklist
- Probate appraisal — an independent opinion of a property’s market value prepared for estate administration, so the executor, estate attorney, or court has documented support for the value of real property in the estate.
- Date-of-death appraisal — a retrospective valuation that estimates what the property was worth as of the decedent’s date of death, rather than as of today.
- Effective date — the specific date the value opinion applies to. For a date-of-death assignment it is a past date, and everything in the analysis is measured against it.
- Alternate valuation date — a different valuation date an estate’s attorney or tax professional may determine is available for tax reporting. The appraiser values the date identified in the engagement; the appraiser does not decide whether an election is available or appropriate.
- Intended users — the specific parties named in the engagement who are entitled to rely on the report, such as the executor, estate attorney, or CPA.
Quick Checklist for Atlanta Executors
The checklist is not a statement of every executor duty. The estate's attorney should advise on fiduciary obligations, court filings, notices, and deadlines.
| Item to gather | Why it matters | What may happen if it is missing |
|---|---|---|
| Date of death and valuation instructions | Establishes the effective date of value | The assignment may be delayed or incorrectly scoped |
| Property access information | Allows inspection and documentation | The appraiser may need a restricted or extraordinary assumption |
| Condition evidence | Helps reconstruct the property’s historical condition | More retrospective research and uncertainty |
| Records of post-death work | Separates later improvements from original condition | The value may be harder to support |
| Prior value and sale records | Provides market and property history | More independent research is required |
| Insurance and repair records | Documents damage, maintenance, and condition | The appraiser may need other evidence |
| Intended report users | Defines who may rely on the report | Attorneys, CPAs, or beneficiaries may not be authorized users |

1. Confirm the Date of Death and Any Alternate Valuation Date
Start by writing down the property owner’s date of death. For most date-of-death appraisal assignments, this is the effective date the appraiser must analyze.
Also ask your CPA or estate attorney whether an alternate valuation date is being considered for the estate’s tax reporting. An advisor may raise IRS Form 706 as part of that discussion, but the decision depends on the estate’s specific facts and should not be made from a general article.
The appraiser should value the date specified in the engagement; the appraiser does not decide whether the estate may or should elect an alternate valuation date.
Tell the appraiser whether you need:
- A valuation as of the date of death
- A valuation as of an alternate date
- Separate values for both dates
- A report for probate, basis documentation, tax reporting, or multiple intended uses
If this information is missing: The appraiser may begin researching the wrong market period. Correcting the effective date later can require additional work and a revised scope.
Key Takeaway: Confirm the effective date in writing before the appraisal starts.
2. Arrange Property Access, or Explain Why It Is Unavailable
Provide the property address, keys, gate codes, alarm instructions, and the name of anyone who can provide access. Tell the appraiser whether the home is:
- Occupied by a family member
- Tenant-occupied
- Vacant
- Secured or inaccessible
- Damaged or unsafe to enter
An interior and exterior inspection generally provides the strongest support for a residential appraisal. If the property has been sold, renovated, damaged, or is not safe to enter, explain that at intake.
If access is unavailable: A retrospective appraisal may still be possible, but the report will rely more heavily on photographs, records, prior listings, third-party descriptions, and other market evidence. The scope may need to disclose limitations or assumptions. Whether an extraordinary assumption or another assignment condition is appropriate is determined under applicable appraisal requirements and should be clearly disclosed in the report.
Key Takeaway: Do not wait until the inspection appointment to mention access problems.
3. Gather Photographs and Records Showing Condition at the Effective Date
A date-of-death appraisal values the property as it existed on the effective date, not necessarily as it appears today. Gather evidence that shows the home’s condition around that time, such as:
- Family photographs
- Vacation or security-camera images
- Prior listing photographs
- Insurance inspection photos
- Contractor reports
- Maintenance records
- Emails describing damage or deferred maintenance
- Photos taken while clearing the property
The appraiser needs to distinguish between ordinary wear, major deferred maintenance, remodeling, storm damage, and other features that could affect market value.
If condition evidence is missing: The appraiser must reconstruct the property’s condition from available sources. That increases the retrospective research burden and may limit the level of certainty available.
Key Takeaway: Preserve old photos before cleaning, renovating, or disposing of property records.
4. Document Work Completed Since the Date of Death
Make a simple timeline of everything done to the property after the owner’s death. Include dates, descriptions, and costs when available:
- Roof replacement
- HVAC replacement
- Kitchen or bathroom remodeling
- Flooring and painting
- Water or fire damage repairs
- Landscaping and tree removal
- Demolition or structural work
- Clearing or removal of personal property
For example, if a damaged roof was replaced six months after the date of death, the appraiser must not treat the new roof as though it existed on the earlier effective date.
If post-death work is undocumented: The appraiser may have difficulty separating the property’s historical condition from later improvements. Invoices, permits, contractor statements, and before-and-after photos are especially useful.
Key Takeaway: A repair completed later does not automatically represent the property’s date-of-death condition.
5. Find Prior Appraisals, Purchase Records, and Listing History
Prior records help the appraiser understand the property’s history and identify market evidence. Gather:
- Earlier appraisals
- Purchase contracts or closing statements
- Deeds and title documents
- Previous MLS listings
- Listing photographs
- Sale brochures
- Prior asking prices and listing dates
- Records of additions or permitted improvements
These documents do not determine the final value by themselves. Instead, they help verify facts such as ownership, gross living area, improvements, condition, and prior market exposure.
If these records are missing: The appraiser can research public records and historical market data, but the process may take longer. Older listings or private transaction details may be difficult to recover.
For background on how estate assignments work, start with Belk’s estate and probate appraisal services in Metro Atlanta, then review the Guide to Estate Appraisal Services.
Key Takeaway: Send historical records even if you are unsure whether they are relevant. The appraiser can determine what belongs in the analysis.

6. Collect Insurance Records and Repair Estimates
Insurance documents can provide useful evidence about property condition, damage, and repair history. Gather:
- Declarations pages
- Claims correspondence
- Adjuster reports
- Repair estimates
- Contractor invoices
- Water, fire, or storm damage records
- Roof, foundation, plumbing, or electrical evaluations
Remember that an insurance valuation and a market-value appraisal answer different questions. Insurance documents can support the condition analysis, but they do not replace a probate appraisal.
If records are missing: The appraiser may need to rely on photographs, interviews, permits, comparable properties, and other historical evidence. This is especially important when the home has been repaired since the owner’s death.
Key Takeaway: Insurance and repair records help show what existed, what was damaged, and what changed.
7. Identify Everyone Who Should Receive or Rely on the Report
Tell the appraiser who needs the report before the assignment begins. Possible intended users may include the executor, estate attorney, CPA or tax professional, or another specifically identified user. A court may review a report, but it is not automatically an intended user merely because the report is filed or provided.
Also explain the intended use: probate administration, estate settlement, basis documentation, potential tax reporting, equitable distribution, or another purpose.
A report is written for a defined use and defined users. Naming those parties at intake helps ensure the scope and report address the estate’s actual needs.
If intended users are omitted: An attorney or CPA may later discover that they cannot rely on the report for the purpose they had in mind. A new assignment or clarification may then be necessary.
Key Takeaway: Tell the appraiser who will rely on the report, not only who is paying for it.
What Happens When Information Is Missing?
Missing information does not always make an appraisal impossible. The good news is that retrospective assignments routinely involve incomplete records. The important issue is how much additional research is needed.
The appraiser may need to:
- Search historical MLS data and archived listings.
- Verify older comparable sales.
- Interview people familiar with the property.
- Review permits, insurance files, and public records.
- Analyze photographs and documents from different dates.
- Explain limitations in the final report.
A current appraisal may be completed quickly when the property is accessible and the effective date is today. A date-of-death appraisal can take longer because the appraiser must reconstruct a past market and avoid using information that was not available on the effective date.
For additional guidance, see The Ultimate Guide to Estate Appraisals for Atlanta Families and How to Avoid Estate Appraisal Pitfalls with Inherited Property.
What You Do Not Need to Worry About
You usually do not need to:
- Deep-clean the house
- Stage rooms like a listing
- Remove every personal item
- Complete cosmetic repairs before inspection
- Resolve beneficiary disagreements before contacting the appraiser, though the estate's attorney should advise on notices, consent, and any court-specific requirements
- Have every document perfectly organized
You should make the property safe to enter and provide access to all relevant areas. The appraiser’s job is to analyze the property objectively, not to judge housekeeping or décor.
If the estate includes inherited land, review Inherited Land in Georgia: What to Do First. Vacant land requires additional information about zoning, access, utilities, acreage, and highest and best use.
How to Order the Appraisal
Before you call, prepare:
- Property address
- Date of death
- Executor or administrator contact information
- Access instructions
- Intended use and intended users
- Available condition and repair records
- Any probate, CPA, or attorney deadline
Belk Appraisal Service Inc. has served Atlanta and surrounding communities since 1988. Belk is a Georgia-licensed appraiser serving Metro Atlanta, and reports are prepared in accordance with applicable USPAP requirements and the agreed intended use, with typical delivery in 2–3 business days after inspection for straightforward assignments. Retrospective, complex, or poorly documented assignments may require more time.
We also provide residential appraisal services throughout Metro Atlanta for homes, condominiums, townhouses, small investment properties, and vacant residential land.
Sources and Authority
This checklist is not a substitute for legal advice and does not identify every duty or filing requirement applicable to an executor or administrator.
- O.C.G.A. § 53-7-30 — Georgia law may require a personal representative to prepare and file an inventory, subject to applicable waivers, exceptions, and court requirements. This statute does not automatically require an independent real-estate appraisal for every estate. (Last verified: September 2026.)
- O.C.G.A. § 53-7-31 — Appraisers may be appointed in certain circumstances where property values are uncertain, subject to the statute and the estate's circumstances. (Last verified: September 2026.)
- Internal Revenue Code § 2032 — law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/26/2032. Alternate valuation election, where the estate's attorney or tax professional determines whether it is available or appropriate.
- IRS Instructions for Form 706 — irs.gov/instructions/i706. Valuation information and appraisal attachment requirements for estates that must file.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. Is it too late to order a date-of-death appraisal?
No. A date-of-death appraisal can often be completed months or years after the property owner died. The appraiser uses historical market data and evidence of the property’s condition as of the effective date. The assignment may take longer when the home has been sold, renovated, cleared, or substantially damaged. Gather photographs, prior listings, repair records, insurance documents, and statements from people familiar with the property. Your attorney or CPA can explain any filing deadlines and how the report fits into the estate process. The sooner you order the appraisal, the easier it may be to preserve reliable condition evidence.
2. Do I need an appraisal for probate in Georgia?
Whether an appraisal is required, and what format the probate court expects, depends on the estate and the applicable instructions. An executor should ask the estate attorney or the appropriate probate professional what must be filed and by when. Even when a particular filing does not require a formal appraisal, an independent report can provide documented support for the property’s value, beneficiary discussions, or later sale decisions. A tax assessment, online estimate, or informal opinion may not address the same effective date or intended use. Belk can discuss the assignment scope with your attorney or CPA before work begins.
3. What if the property cannot be inspected inside?
Tell the appraiser immediately if the property is inaccessible, occupied by someone who will not permit entry, unsafe, or already demolished or renovated. A retrospective appraisal may still be possible using exterior observations, historical photographs, prior listings, permits, insurance files, repair records, and comparable properties. However, the report must accurately disclose what was and was not observed. Limited access can increase the research burden and may require assumptions or additional explanation. Do not arrange unauthorized entry. Instead, provide every available record and ask the appraiser and your attorney how to proceed.
4. Can I use a tax assessment or online estimate instead?
A tax assessment and online estimate are not the same as an independent appraisal. Tax assessments are produced for taxation and may use a different date, methodology, or level of property detail. Online estimates generally rely on public records and statistical models without inspecting the home. Neither may document the property’s condition on the date of death or explain adjustments to comparable sales. If your attorney, CPA, court, or other professional needs defensible support, ask what type of report is appropriate. A Georgia-licensed appraiser can scope the assignment for the intended use.
Schedule Your Atlanta Probate Appraisal
Gathering these seven items before you order helps the appraisal begin with a clear effective date, reliable property history, and the correct intended users. If records are incomplete, do not guess, explain what is missing and let the appraiser identify the best alternatives.
Belk Appraisal Service Inc. has appraised more than 10,000 properties and brings more than 35 years of Atlanta-area experience to residential, estate, probate, and date-of-death assignments.
To schedule an appraisal, call (404) 259-7099, email Belks@belkappraisal.net, or request an estate and date-of-death appraisal.
Tax and legal disclaimer: This article provides general educational information only. It is not tax or legal advice, and it does not determine whether an estate must file a return, use Form 706, elect an alternate valuation date, or receive a particular tax result. IRS guidance and individual circumstances vary. Consult a qualified CPA and estate attorney about your specific estate. An appraisal is an opinion of value for the stated effective date and intended use; it does not guarantee any tax outcome or court decision.